About UsIssuesAct NowGovernment AffairsEventsNewsroomlounge

FCC Ex Parte with DIRECTV and DISH NETWORK regarding the Comcast-NBCU Joint Venture

Submission Date: 

October 20, 2010


The Hon. Julius Genachowski
Federal Communications Commission
445 12th Street, S.W.
Washington, D.C. 20554

Re: Applications of Comcast Corporation, General Electric Company, and NBC Universal, Inc., MB Docket No. 10-56

Dear Chairman Genachowski:

DIRECTV, DISH Network L.L.C., and the American Cable Association ("ACA") are writing with respect to FOX Network's decision to block those with Cablevision IP addresses from accessing FOX content on its affiliated websites, Fox.com and Hulu.com. This episode confirms the need for Commission action to safeguard MVPD subscribers' access to online content in the Comcast/NBCU proceeding. If FOX, an entity with no affiliation to a distribution platform, was willing to deny certain viewers access to its online content in order to gain a negotiating advantage, a vertically integrated Comcast/NBCU would have an even greater incentive and ability to take similar action.

It appears that FOX's primary motivation to block Hulu and Fox.com traffic was to exert pressure in its retransmission consent dispute with Cablevision. Without appropriate safeguards, it is reasonable to assume that Comcast/NBCU would take similar action against non-Comcast broadband subscribers in the event of a dispute, because it could both increase its leverage in carriage negotiations and encourage subscriber defection to Comcast's own video and broadband platforms. The mere threat of using this type of embargo would surely apply upward pressure on prices for Comcast/NBCU local, regional, and national programming.

FOX's action also seems to belie Comcast's claim that a combined Comcast-NBCU with "a minority, non-controlling interest in Hulu" could not "‘cause' Hulu to refuse to deal with third parties."1 FOX now holds a similar "minority, non-controlling interest" in Hulu, but appears to have had no difficulty "causing" Hulu to "refuse to deal" with Cablevision subscribers. The Commission should investigate as part of this proceeding whether Hulu blocked subscribers unilaterally at FOX's request, or with the cooperation of Hulu's other owners, as that issue bears directly on Comcast's ability to use Hulu for its own strategic ends in the future.

DIRECTV, DISH, and ACA believe that FOX's use of Fox.com and Hulu is a timely illustration both of the extent to which online content has become an integral part of the television viewing landscape and of the opportunities for disadvantaging MVPDs this development would present to Comcast/NBCU. If the Commission is to approve the pending applications, it must condition such approval to ensure that Comcast/NBCU's online programming remains available to all MVPD viewers-including online viewers using broadband platforms other than Comcast's own-on a fair and non-discriminatory basis.

Respectfully submitted,


By: __/s/_________________________
Susan Eid
Sr. Vice President, Government Affairs


By: __/s/_________________________
Jeffrey H. Blum
Senior Vice-President and Deputy General Counsel


By: __/s/_________________________
Ross J. Lieberman
Vice President of Government Affairs


101020 Ex Parte re FOX (Final).pdf135.28 KB

Contact Us

Please use the information below to get in touch with the American Cable Association.

  • American Cable Association
    Seven Parkway Center
    Suite 755
    Pittsburgh, PA 15220-3704
  • phone:412-922-8300
    contact us
Connect Hometown America
Join the Campaign

Enter your email address and zip code below to begin the process of creating an account on the ACA website.